Disclosure: we make MentorPRO. We have tried to describe every platform fairly, using each company’s public website and review profiles as of October 2026. Pricing changes, so ask each vendor for a current quote.
Good volunteer mentoring software helps a small staff keep volunteers trained, matched well, in safe contact with their mentees, and supported when a match starts to struggle. Evaluate it on eight things: the screening handoff, volunteer training, matching, staff-visible messaging, check-ins, volunteer retention, reporting, and a price your grant budget can carry.
Key takeaways
- Volunteer programs fail quietly: matches close early, and volunteers drift away. Pick software that shows you trouble early.
- Background checks usually live in a separate system. Ask exactly how screening status reaches the mentoring platform.
- Matching and early support matter more than features lists. Intake characteristics predict which matches close early (Kupersmidt et al., 2017).
- Compare first-year cost, not just the license fee.
This guide is for coordinators at Big Brothers Big Sisters agencies, youth-serving nonprofits, and school-based and community programs serving young people from middle school through young adulthood. It draws on the research of Dr. Jean Rhodes, Director of the Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring at UMass Boston and co-founder of MentorPRO, and on what we have seen with BBBS agencies and National Guard Youth ChalleNGe programs.
What makes volunteer mentoring software different from general volunteer management software?
General volunteer management software tracks shifts, hours and sign-ups. Volunteer mentoring software has to support a relationship that lasts months or years between an adult and a young person. That means matching, ongoing training, safe communication that staff can see, and regular check-ins on how the match is going.
Many programs use two tools: a CRM for intake, screening and case notes, and a participant-facing platform where mentors and mentees talk, set goals and check in. Decide which jobs you need covered before you take a demo.
How should the platform handle recruiting and background check handoff?
Most programs run background checks through a dedicated screening vendor, so the mentoring platform rarely does the check itself. What matters is the handoff: how a volunteer’s cleared status gets into the platform, who can see it, and what stops an uncleared volunteer from being matched or messaging a young person.
Ask every vendor to show you this step live: a direct integration, a Salesforce or CRM sync, or a manual status field. Manual can work for a small program, but name who owns it. For example, Innovative Mentoring Software, which is built for youth mentoring programs, lists volunteer background checks as an add-on on its Premium and Enterprise plans that requires a Sterling Volunteers contract. Screening and background checks typically stay in the program’s existing system, and MentorPRO connects to existing systems through SSO, Salesforce and API integrations.
Does the software train volunteers before and during the match?
Volunteers forget most of a one-time orientation. Look for training that starts before the match and continues in short pieces during it, especially around the moments that end matches: missed meetings, mismatched expectations, and hard conversations.
Ask whether training lives inside the same app volunteers already use, whether staff can see who completed it, and whether it is grounded in research. MentorPRO Academy offers science-backed training and certification for mentors, mentees and staff, and MentorAI, an AI mentor co-pilot, coaches mentors in the moment without replacing them or your staff.
How does the platform support better matching?
Matching is where early closure starts or is prevented. Kupersmidt and colleagues (2017, American Journal of Community Psychology) found that characteristics collected at intake predict which youth mentoring matches close prematurely. A good platform helps staff use that intake data, rather than matching on proximity and availability alone.
Ask what the matching is based on and whether staff keep the final decision. MatchPRO, MentorPRO’s research-based matching, uses factors drawn from mentoring science, including research on which mentor and youth similarities predict longer matches (Raposa et al., 2019). In a field test of 115 matches, 9% of MatchPRO pairs closed early versus 32% of manual matches (Rhodes et al., manuscript in preparation). Treat that as early evidence, and ask any vendor for its own numbers.
Is messaging safe and visible to staff?
For programs serving minors, mentors and mentees should not need to trade personal phone numbers or social media handles. Staff should be able to see conversations, not just know that they happened. This protects young people, protects volunteers, and gives coordinators context when a match needs help.
Ask who can read messages, how the vendor handles data security (MentorPRO is SOC 2 compliant), and whether the app works on the phones your families actually have. MentorPRO Secure Messaging lets staff see conversations and runs on web, iOS and Android.
Do check-ins help staff catch struggling matches early?
The match you hear about too late is the one that already ended. Short, regular check-ins from mentors and mentees give coordinators a signal before a volunteer quietly stops showing up. The test is simple: can a coordinator with 60 matches see, in one screen, which ones need a call this week?
Ask how check-ins are prompted, how often, and what staff see when a response looks worrying. MentorPRO includes check-ins that help staff catch struggling participants early. Research supports the point: among 2,572 first-year college students, more check-ins and student-initiated messages were associated with higher end-of-year GPA after propensity score matching (Werntz et al., 2026, International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education).
How does the software help retain volunteers?
Volunteers stay when they feel useful and supported. Goal setting gives each meeting a purpose, training arrives when needed, and staff can reach out before frustration sets in. Ask vendors how mentors rate the experience, and ask to see the survey data behind the answer.
What reporting do funders and boards expect?
Funders, boards and national offices want match counts and match length, plus evidence that matches are active: messages, goals and check-ins. Ask to see a real report, not a mockup, and make sure you can export the data yourself.
Here is what that looks like in practice. Six Big Brothers Big Sisters agencies use MentorPRO to keep matches active between meetings with secure messaging, goals and check-ins, and staff can see that activity in one place. Read the Big Brothers Big Sisters case study.
How much does volunteer mentoring software cost?
Pricing models vary, so compare the full first-year cost. Innovative Mentoring Software prices per staff user, billed annually: Basic is $32 per user per month (1 to 5 staff users) plus $200 setup; Premium is $46 per user per month (the rate requires 3 or more users) plus $1,000 setup and $350 per year for survey and form integration; Enterprise is $64 per user per month (10 or more users) plus $5,000 setup. Some features are add-ons. MentorPRO plans start at $5,999 per year, and most programs invest $6,000 to $35,000 per year depending on size and support.
When you build a grant budget, include setup, data migration, training, background check fees from your screening vendor, and staff time. A cheaper license that needs more staff hours can cost more.
What should be on your evaluation checklist?
| Area | Question to ask in the demo | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Screening handoff | Show me how a cleared background check reaches your platform. | A clear integration or process, with a named owner, that keeps uncleared volunteers from being matched or messaging youth. |
| Training | What training do volunteers get before and during the match? | Research-based, inside the app, with completion visible to staff. |
| Matching | What is matching based on, and what are your early closure numbers? | Research-based factors, staff keep the final decision, data shared openly. |
| Messaging | Can staff read every conversation? | Yes, with no personal contact details exchanged. |
| Check-ins | How do I find struggling matches this week? | One view showing which matches need attention. |
| Retention | How do mentors rate the experience? | Survey data, not just testimonials. |
| Reporting | Show me a real funder report and an export. | Match activity plus outcomes, exportable by your team. |
| Security | What certifications do you hold? | SOC 2 or equivalent, plus clear data ownership terms. |
| Price | What is the full first-year cost? | License, setup, migration, training and add-ons in writing. |
Frequently asked questions
What is volunteer mentoring software?
Volunteer mentoring software helps programs recruit, train, match and support volunteer mentors and the young people they work with. It usually includes matching, messaging, check-ins, goal setting and reporting. It differs from general volunteer management software, which focuses on shifts and hours.
Does mentoring software run background checks?
Usually not directly. Screening and background checks typically stay in the program’s existing system or with a dedicated screening vendor. Ask each vendor how cleared status reaches the mentoring platform and what keeps uncleared volunteers from being matched or contacting youth.
Is it safe for volunteers to message minors through an app?
It can be safer than texting, if staff can see every conversation and no personal contact details are exchanged. Ask about data security certifications such as SOC 2 and about who has access to messages.
Can volunteer mentoring software work for middle school programs?
Yes. Look for an app that is simple for younger users, staff visibility into all messages, and settings that fit your program’s rules for minors. MentorPRO serves middle school, high school, college and young adult programs.
How do I pay for mentoring software with grant funds?
Many programs include software as a program or evaluation cost in grant budgets. Get a written first-year quote that covers setup, training and add-ons, and choose a tool whose reports match what your funder asks for.
CTA: Want to see how MentorPRO handles screening handoff, check-ins and funder reports for a volunteer program like yours? Book a demo.
Keep reading.

Best Peer Mentoring Platforms for Colleges in 2026
The best peer mentoring software for colleges gives trained student mentors simple tools to stay in touch with mentees, and gives staff the oversight to spot problems early…
Read more
Best Mentoring Software for Impact Tracking in 2026
Mentoring impact measurement means tracking whether matches last, whether pairs meet, and whether young people move toward outcomes such as GPA, retention and persistence, then reporting that to…
Read more
Mentor Collective Alternatives for Universities in 2026
Mentor Collective Alternatives for Universities in 2026 Disclosure: we make MentorPRO. We have tried to describe every platform fairly, using each company's public website and review profiles as…
Read moreSee MentorPRO built around your program.
Tell us a little about your program and a member of our partner success team will reach out.
