Independent evaluation (RAND)
What RAND found
In 2026, the RAND Corporation published its tenth annual report on Youth ChalleNGe, sponsored by the Office of the Secretary of Defense. The report examined the post-residential mentoring pilot at the six original pilot sites, based on conversations with program staff in 2024 and 2025.
RAND also reported that staff no longer needed to process mentor applications, train mentors or track down mentors to learn what graduates were doing, and that sites saw more communication with families during and after the residential phase. RAND said it expects the pilot to produce more positive outcomes among graduates than the traditional mentor model, but that it is too early to measure the difference.
What RAND flagged
Staff asked for more training on the pilot approach, on expectations and indicators of success, and on the MentorPRO app itself. RAND noted that the pilot was rolled out soon after development, with no off-the-shelf training available, and recommended a stronger training curriculum before wider adoption. Several sites worried about phone use among cadets and graduates and whether graduates would use the app, and one site said many of its cadets come from areas with connectivity problems. Some sites said that tracking placements for 24 months may require more staff or risk burnout.
RAND’s findings come from conversations with staff at six sites. They describe staff experience and expectations. RAND said it was too early to measure differences in cadet outcomes.
Read the report: National Guard Youth ChalleNGe: Program Progress in 2024-2025 (RAND, 2026)